Book Review: Archaeology. The Conceptual Challenge
The Prehistoric Society (Review by David Mullin)
Archaeology. The Conceptual Challenge, by Timothy Insoll, Duckworth & Co. 2007
This short book asks a series of timely questions about the nature of archaeological enquiry; the place of humans in the natural world; the nature of culture and the language used in archaeological writing. At the core of the book is a call for a reconsideration of the implicit assumptions and concepts we engage as archaeologists and the ways in which our experience of the modern(-ist) world affects our reading of the archaeological materials we encounter. Does mass access to quick and easy international travel, for example, have implications for how we understand concepts of ‘the local’ and does a shrinking world mean that we place less stress on place, distance and the concept of the journey? Can the products of a society which is dependent on the written word really understand what it is to be pre-literate? Does the rise of an ‘on demand’ culture which is less dependent on face-to-face interaction have implications for understandings of tradition, history and socialisation?
Chapter 2 of the book explores how globalisation has affected archaeological interpretation and Insoll attacks recent, ego-centred work (such as phenomenological studies), calling for a reassessment of how we think about social groups and the concept of community. The nature of materiality is also discussed, as is the changing nature of diversity and what this means. These themes are expanded in Chapter 3, which deals in detail with phenomenology. Insoll suggests that, although the biological equipment for interpreting sensual data may be the same in the present as they were in the past, the context in which the data gathered from this equipment is interpreted is very different. Rather than assuming similarities in emotional and sensory frameworks between the past and present, we should, instead, try and prove that this was the case. Quite how this could be done is not, unfortunately, addressed.
See the above page for the entire review.
- Book Review: Describing And Interpreting The Past
Bryn Mawr Classical Review (Reviewed by Sveta Matskevich) Cătălin Pavel, Describing and Interpreting the Past: European and American Approaches to the Written Record of the Excavation. Bucureşti: Editura Universităţii din Bucureşti While...
- Travel: Western Desert
Al Masry Al Youm “The very basic core of a man’s living spirit is his passion for adventure. The joy of life comes from our encounters with new experiences, and hence there is no greater joy than to have an endlessly changing horizon, for each day...
- Left Coast Summer Hardback Sale
Left Coast Press Most of these are not relevant to Egyptology but some of them look at archaeological methodologies and ideas as a whole, which might be of interest to some of you. I've left the entire list as it was sent to me in case some of you...
- Book Review: Archaeology - The Conceptual Challenge
The Prehistoric Society (Review by David Mullin) Of potential interest to anyone interested in prehistory: This short book asks a series of timely questions about the nature of archaeological enquiry; the place of humans in the natural world; the nature...
- Book Review: Alexander The Great In His World
Bryn Mawr Classical Review (Review by Cheryl Golden) Carol G. Thomas, Alexander the Great in His World. Oxford: Blackwell Publishing, 2007 Table of Contents Carol Thomas' contribution to the voluminous scholarship on the "Great" Alexander III of...